Sell Your Graded Cards for Cash
Send a few photos, we drive to you, and pay fair cash on the spot. No mail-in, no consignment.
Rated 4.7 on Google · 23 reviews
What we pay for
Graded cards are the easiest category to price fairly, because the grade removes most of the guesswork. That usually means a cleaner, higher offer for you. We buy PSA, BGS/Beckett, and SGC slabs across all four major sports, vintage through modern.
What a slab is worth comes down to the card, the grade, and the population. A low-pop high-grade vintage star or a gem-mint modern rookie can command a large multiple of the same card raw, because the market pays a premium for certainty and eye appeal.
We pay against current sold comps for that exact card in that exact grade. PSA 10s and BGS 9.5/10s of key rookies, vintage stars in PSA 7–9, and scarce slabbed autos and numbered parallels are where the strongest numbers live.
Crossgrade candidates and undergraded cards are fine too, and we account for them. We also buy graded lots and full slab collections in one transaction, which is often the smoother path than selling slabs one at a time and paying fees on each.
If you have raw cards you think are grade-worthy, mention them. We buy those as well and factor in the upside. Send photos showing the label and grade clearly, and we'll bring you a cash offer.
What we buy
- PSA, BGS/Beckett, and SGC slabs across all sports
- High-grade modern rookies (PSA 10, BGS 9.5/10)
- Vintage stars in PSA/SGC 5–9
- Slabbed autos and numbered parallels
- Full graded lots and slab collections
What we pass on (honestly)
- All leads accepted; low-value slabs still get an honest number
- Damaged/cracked slabs valued as the raw card
- Questionable/altered slabs flagged and valued accordingly
Three steps to cash
- 01
Send photos
Snap the boxes, binders, or slabs and upload them right here. That's how we size up the buy before we drive out.
- 02
We drive to you
We come to your door anywhere within about 3 hours of Goshen, farther for large collections. No shipping, no waiting.
- 03
Cash on the spot
You get a fair offer in person and cash in hand the same day. No consignment, no fees, no obligation.
Graded Cards: common questions
- Do you buy PSA, BGS, and SGC all the same?
- We buy all three. Market premiums differ slightly by grader and card, and we account for that. Each slab is priced against sold comps for that exact grade and holder.
- Why is a graded card worth more than the same card raw?
- The grade guarantees condition and authenticity, which buyers pay a premium for, especially at the top grades. A PSA 10 rookie can be worth many times the raw card. Send photos of the label and we'll price it.
- Should I sell my slabs individually or as a lot?
- Selling the lot to us in one transaction avoids per-card fees and shipping risk and gets you paid at once. We're happy to buy a single slab or an entire graded collection.
- I have raw cards I think could grade well. Do you want those too?
- Yes. Point them out and we'll factor the grading upside into the offer. You don't have to grade them first.
Let's take a look at what you have
No pressure, no obligation. Just an honest answer and a fair cash offer.